Security Deposit Deductions: What Landlords Can Charge


A landlord can deduct from a security deposit for unpaid rent, damage beyond normal wear and tear, and cleaning needed to bring the unit back to its move-in condition. Every deduction has to be provable and itemized on time, and that is where most landlords lose. The deduction is rarely the problem. The paperwork behind it usually is. We manage rentals for investors in Southern New Jersey, and we treat the deposit as the end of a process that starts with a documented move-in inspection.
TL;DR
Deductible: unpaid rent, tenant-caused damage beyond normal wear and tear, and cleaning that restores move-in condition.
Not deductible: faded paint, minor scuffs, a few small nail holes, and routine between-tenant cleaning.
Every line needs an amount, a reason and proof (photos, invoices or receipts), delivered inside your state’s deadline.
Missing the deadline or deducting in bad faith can cost you the deposit and a penalty of up to twice the amount in some states.
Your best defense is built at move-in: dated photos, a signed condition checklist and a clear lease.
Table of Contents
What you can deduct from a security deposit
State law sets the exact list, but the core is consistent. A California court self-help guide lists cleaning to restore the unit to move-in cleanliness, repair of damage caused by the tenant or guests beyond normal wear and tear, restoring or replacing included personal property, and rent owed. The Wyoming Judicial Branch gives a similar short list and adds other costs the lease allows.

Two more points from that Wyoming page matter to any landlord. Extra money collected at move-in, other than an application fee, is treated as a security deposit, so labeling it a cleaning fee, key fee or pet fee does not make it keepable. And a deposit cannot be called nonrefundable: the City of Santa Monica’s deposit explainer says plainly that a nonrefundable deposit is not legal.
A working deductions list
Use this as a screen before you add a line to a statement:
Item | Usually deductible? | What you need |
Unpaid rent and lease-defined charges | Yes | Ledger and lease |
Holes from mounted shelving or TVs, gouged walls | Yes | Move-in vs. move-out photos, repair invoice |
Burns, pet damage, broken fixtures | Yes | Photos, invoice or receipt |
Grease-caked appliances, trash left behind | Yes, as cleaning | Photos, cleaner invoice |
Faded paint, minor scuffs | No | Normal wear |
A few small nail holes | No | Normal wear |
Routine vacuuming and dusting between tenants | Generally no | Your cost of doing business |
Carpet worn from foot traffic | No | Normal wear |
The list is not a legal guarantee for your state. Check your state statute, and if a charge is large or contested, talk to a New Jersey or local landlord-tenant attorney.
Normal wear versus damage
This is the line that decides most disputes. Normal wear is what happens when people simply live in a home. Damage is what happens beyond that. Nolo’s guide puts a few small tack or nail holes on the wear side, and lots of picture holes or gouges that need patching and repainting on the damage side. It makes the same split between faded paint (wear) and water damage (damage), and between a worn refrigerator gasket (wear) and a broken shelf (damage). It also notes that the longer a tenant stays, the more wear you should expect.
Two rules keep you safe in practice:
Charge for damage, never for wear. One Illinois landlord attorney puts it this way: if you are unsure which it is, treat it as wear.
Prorate for age. A carpet that is eight years old has used up most of its life. Billing a tenant new-carpet prices for it invites a reduction, so charge only the remaining value of the item. Where a state or the lease is silent on depreciation, apply it anyway.
The burden of proof sits with you. You have to show the condition at move-in, the condition at move-out and that the difference exceeds normal wear. Nolo’s guidance is to use move-in and move-out checklists with date-stamped photos and video.
Cleaning charges: restoring condition, not resetting the unit
Cleaning is the most common source of overreach. The standard is move-in condition, not spotless. The Berkeley Rent Board says a landlord cannot claim professional cleaning or carpet cleaning against the deposit unless it is reasonably necessary to return the unit to its starting condition, less ordinary wear.
In practice:
Chargeable: grease and food in the oven and refrigerator, heavy bathroom buildup, trash and abandoned belongings, pet urine, stains that need professional treatment.
Not chargeable: the vacuuming, dusting and wipe-down you would do for any new tenant.
Never twice: if you bill to clean a stain and then bill to replace the same flooring, you have charged for the same problem twice.
Least costly reasonable fix: do not bill for full replacement when a repair or cleaning would solve it.
If the unit was professionally cleaned before the tenant moved in, say so on the move-in checklist and keep the invoice. It makes a move-out cleaning charge far easier to support.
How to itemize deductions so they hold up
An itemized statement is a written list of each deduction, its amount and the reason for it, sent with any remaining balance of the deposit. Vague lines are the quickest way to lose a dispute. The standard worth working to: each charge on its own line, with a reason and a document behind it. “General damage: $800” does not work. “Drywall repair, bedroom wall: $350, contractor invoice dated [date]” does.
Build each statement in this order
Start with the deposit and any interest owed. In some states interest must be returned to the tenant.
List each deduction separately, with amount, reason and a reference to the proof.
Attach the proof. Use invoices for contractor work, receipts for materials, and before-and-after photos. If you did the work yourself, describe it with the hours spent and a reasonable hourly rate.
Show the math: deposit plus interest, minus deductions, equals the refund.
Send it on time, by the delivery method your state requires.
This is also your security deposit accounting. Keep tenant deposits in a separate account where your state requires it, and record the money as a liability you owe the tenant, not as rental income. It becomes income only when you apply it to a valid charge. Your accountant or bookkeeper can set up the entries for your entity.
Where a state sets a dollar threshold, follow it. California’s courts guide says that when deductions exceed $125, copies of invoices or receipts must be attached. The City of Pasadena states the same threshold and adds that a tenant can request a pre-move-out inspection with 48 hours’ written notice, after which the landlord gives an itemized list of repairs and cleaning.
Deadlines and penalties vary by state
Timing is where careful landlords still get caught. Some examples from official sources:
California: 21 days after move-out to return the deposit or send an itemized statement, per the state courts guide.
Connecticut: return the deposit with interest or give written notice of damages within 21 days of the end of the tenancy, and missing the deadline can make you liable for twice the deposit.
Illinois: a 2024 amendment extended the rules to every residential lessor. You must deliver an itemized statement within 30 days of the tenant vacating, and a bad-faith refusal to itemize can mean twice the deposit plus fees.
New Jersey: the Security Deposit Act sets a 30-day window from the end of the lease for returning the deposit and any interest, along with the itemized statement of deductions. The clock runs from the lease end, not from the key handover. Read the statute or our New Jersey deduction mistakes breakdown for a real example of how a $2,600 deduction turned into a $6,800 mistake.
Rules also change. California’s one-month deposit cap took effect after July 1, 2024, according to the state’s Department of Justice guide. The Berkeley Rent Board states that, from April 1, 2025, California landlords must photograph the unit after regaining possession and before any repair or cleaning they plan to deduct, and give those photos to the tenant with the statement. If you own in California, our California rental laws overview is a good starting point. Always confirm the current text with your state’s official page before you send a statement.
Build the defense before the tenant leaves
A deduction is only as strong as the evidence of the starting condition. That means a documented move-in inspection with photos and video that the tenant acknowledges, plus periodic inspections so damage shows up early rather than at move-out. We lay out the routine in our guides to the move-in inspection and the property inspection schedule.
At move-out, do the walkthrough with the same checklist and the same angles, as covered in our move-out inspection steps. Photograph the unit after you regain possession and before any cleaning or repair. Then get invoices for the work. A bad turnover can be expensive, as in our $14,150 rental turnover example, and the deposit rarely covers all of it, which is why recoverable charges need to be documented line by line.
Tenants also have rights in this window, and reading the tenant-side protections around the end of a tenancy helps you see what a tenant or a court will expect to see from you.

A worked example
Say a tenant leaves after three years. The deposit is $2,000.
Line | Amount | Proof |
Unpaid final month’s rent | $400 | Ledger |
Drywall repair and paint, living room (large gouges, 4 ft wide) | $350 | Contractor invoice, photos |
Oven and refrigerator degreasing | $120 | Cleaner invoice, photos |
Carpet replacement, bedroom (pet urine), prorated for age | $300 | Invoice, photos, age of carpet |
Total deductions | $1,170 | |
Refund | $830 | Plus any interest owed |
Left off: repainting the rest of the unit after three years of occupancy and routine cleaning. Both are normal turnover costs. The statement is shorter, easier to defend, and a judge reading it sees a landlord who deducted only for damage.
Perspective: what we do with deposits
Our team is led by an investor and a management team that works with investors, so we look at a deposit the way you do: as part of the return on the property, not a pot to be emptied at move-out. Overreaching on a deposit tends to cost more than it recovers. That is why we emphasize compliance and risk mitigation in how we manage. We build custom management processes around each owner’s properties, and tenant screening, maintenance coordination and vendor oversight all feed the evidence that supports a clean, defensible deposit statement. Our approach is simple: document the condition at the start, hold vendors to written invoices, and put only provable charges on the statement. As a veteran-owned company, we value doing it by the book. Main
Let us handle the move-out paperwork
If you would rather not spend your weekends on walkthroughs, vendor invoices and statement deadlines, our residential property management service covers tenant screening, rent collection, leasing and maintenance coordination for landlords and investors in Southern New Jersey and nearby suburbs.

We also provide association management for condos and HOAs. Tell us about your property and we will show you how we would run your turnovers.
FAQ
Can a landlord deduct for nail holes?
A few small nail or tack holes are normal wear and tear, so you should not charge for them. Many holes from mounted shelves, TVs or heavy pictures, or gouges that need patching and repainting, are tenant damage and can be deducted when documented.
Can I charge a cleaning fee out of the deposit?
Yes, but only to restore the unit to its move-in cleanliness, such as for grease in appliances, trash or heavy bathroom buildup. Routine between-tenant cleaning is generally your own cost, and a flat nonrefundable cleaning fee collected up front is treated as part of the deposit in some states.
What should an itemized deduction list include?
Each deduction should be on its own line with an amount, a reason and its supporting proof, such as an invoice or photos. Show the deposit, any interest, the total deductions and the refund. Send it by the deadline and delivery method your state requires.
How should I account for a security deposit?
Keep the money in a separate account where your state requires it, and book it as a liability owed to the tenant, not as income. Record each deduction only when you apply it to a valid charge. Ask your accountant how to set up the entries for your entity.
Sources
Recommended

Comments